write-up for Campbell and Sturgeon awards

[mckitterick]

On SFSite, Dave Truesdale posts this write-up for F&SF about the Campbell Award and Sturgeon Award and this year's presentation.

The article includes the full text of Betty Hull's comments about Ben Bova's TITAN (this year's John W. Campbell Memorial Award winner), James Gunn's comments about Robert Charles Wilson's "The Cartesian Theater" (this year's Theodore Sturgeon Memorial Award winner), and a short interview with Wilson. Wilson won the Campbell Award (tied with Williamson's TERRAFORMING EARTH) in 2002 for THE CHRONOLITHS and placed second last year with SPIN.

Best,
Chris

Comments

[shsilver.livejournal.com]

To be fair, it is actually posted on F&SF, for whom Dave is a columnist. F&SF just uses SF Site as a hosting service, much as I do.

[pyropyga.livejournal.com]

That's an interesting write-up indeed, and I'm going to be reading Hull's remarks a couple of times when I have more time this evening. A few notes, however. Much as I pointed out in the prior thread on the Campbell's, the text "discuss among its members the novels published during the year and to arrive at a consensus choice" does not seem to reflect the process described, and this is substantively misleading. Also, I'm still hoping for answers to those other administrative questions I had, if possible.

Спасибо за информацию

[andrafyso.livejournal.com]

Писака давай зачетку (http://7wp.ru/)

Интересный блог

[edwinetona.livejournal.com]

Все прикольно написано (http://7wp.ru/)