![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Re: this:
http://www.congress.org/congressorg/issues/alert/?alertid=5834001&content_dir=ua_congressorg
and this:
http://snopes.com/politics/military/draft.asp
Y'know, I would have no problem with requiring two years of national service right after high school of anyone who wishes to be an American citizen. Remember Heinlein? Sorta like that. But I disagree with Heinlein and others that it must be military service. In fact, that would counter the notion that this is good for America, because people would be force to do something they might be morally opposed to and cause protests.
However, most people (yes, most) right outta high school (or new to the country and seeking citizenship) ought to spend some time doing good for their country. Two years of paid volunteerism, seeing how the bottom half lives while becoming part of the country and learning who they are: That seems like a good idea.
If this resolution spelled out that the individual could pick their path (community projects, working with the homeless, cleaning up industrial spills, you name it), then I would support it! Honestly, how many kids are ready for college at 17 or 18? But I, for one, would have fought being forced into the military; heck, I would have bitched about having to do other service, but then kids of that age bitch just on principle.
How about you? Would you support mandatory national service where the hopeful citizen would be able to choose their path? A true rite of passage to citizenship. I predict it would increase the percentage of voters, too.
Chris
http://www.congress.org/congressorg/issues/alert/?alertid=5834001&content_dir=ua_congressorg
and this:
http://snopes.com/politics/military/draft.asp
Y'know, I would have no problem with requiring two years of national service right after high school of anyone who wishes to be an American citizen. Remember Heinlein? Sorta like that. But I disagree with Heinlein and others that it must be military service. In fact, that would counter the notion that this is good for America, because people would be force to do something they might be morally opposed to and cause protests.
However, most people (yes, most) right outta high school (or new to the country and seeking citizenship) ought to spend some time doing good for their country. Two years of paid volunteerism, seeing how the bottom half lives while becoming part of the country and learning who they are: That seems like a good idea.
If this resolution spelled out that the individual could pick their path (community projects, working with the homeless, cleaning up industrial spills, you name it), then I would support it! Honestly, how many kids are ready for college at 17 or 18? But I, for one, would have fought being forced into the military; heck, I would have bitched about having to do other service, but then kids of that age bitch just on principle.
How about you? Would you support mandatory national service where the hopeful citizen would be able to choose their path? A true rite of passage to citizenship. I predict it would increase the percentage of voters, too.
Chris
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
From:
no subject
So I agree with Heinlein. In fact, I've though about starting a new political party. You know, The Dead Heinleins or something. Platforms being that you must serve to earn full citizenship and that we primarily deal (nationally) with policy that positively affects society for at least three generations into the future. That would preclude stupid crap like drilling in Alaska, allowing rainforests to be destroyed, and on and on while supporting development of alternative fuels, promoting space development, and so on.
I whole-heartedly agree: Give those who serve benies that make it worth staying in the service. As I wrote in another reply, at least as good as the current military gets, plus a lifetime-service path with raises in salary and rank to retain those who really love the work.
Chris